Search This Blog

Jul 29, 2010

Why to research opinion leaders?

Over the last few years, political campaigners and especially PR and marketing professionals have rediscovered the concept of opinion leaders. Look through Seth Godin's Blog or Adam Singer's The Future Buzz, for example. These two guys are very popular and considered advanced in web marketing and PR strategies. I think nobody would blame them in stupid commitment to the old or not working theories. However, they often speak about how to take advantage of "powerful bloggers", "tribe leaders", "buzz generators" to build a successful brand or winning marketing campaign. I also can point at other famous people shouting about an extreme value of opinion leaders in business and politics, like Malcolm Gladwell (2002) with his The Tipping Point and Emanuel Rosen with his The Anatomy of Buzz.

Yet while the marketing gurus are actively targeting opinion leaders, academic researchers stay strangely disconnected from these industry trends. I even once have got a piece of advice from the very respected professor to give up working with the opinion leadership concept and two-step flow theory as both are, he says, out-of-date. Well, I do agree that the theory has been revealed for the academic circles quite long ago, though this fact does not make it irrelevant. Moreover, I believe that our social habits (like how we communicate, make friends, put or lose trust in someone, etc.) migrate to the online communication including social networks and blogs. So, my logic is that we still have opinion leaders, but now some of them exist in the online environment. Therefore the concept of opinion leadership is still relevant, but needs to be studied already with regard to the web.

Furthermore, there are several major themes, which academic researchers generally recognize as "valid". Some of them I have mentioned already in the previous post as my three hypotheses. Now I would mention another thing which seems to be important. These are three dimensions developed by Katz (1957) for "offline" opinion leaders, but they perfectly work for online environment as well:

Who one is - this includes certain personality characteristics or values held the individual (like being creative, able to express the ideas and attract the attention of others);

What one knows - this includes the degree of knowledge and expertise that one has about a particular issue (I would also add here the skills and desire to share this knowledge and expertise); and

Whom one knows - this includes the number of contacts one has around (in online world this is exactly about the size of networks).

A combination of these three dimensions build an image of opinion leaders and helps them not only buzz attention, but also, perhaps more importantly, shape the opinion of others on the certain issues, products, or behaviour.
Enhanced by Zemanta

The goal - it is important.

Until recently I felt very difficult to word the goal of my research. Even in general. Of course I had to define it from the very beginning, when I was asked to submit my research plan while applying for the PhD course. Of course, I did so. However, it's turned out to be two different things - what you state in the research plan as your goal and what you understand as a goal when you are really about starting the practical part of your research. For me it was the pain. Now I try to word it as precisely as I can, though it still is not precise enough. So, 


The GOAL of my research is (1) to clarify confusing differences (between opinion leaders and influential bloggers) in conceptualization and measurement; and (2) to provide guidance on how my study can be translated into successful (political, marketing) communication campaigns. 


I know, I have also to specify my focus, because when I say political OR marketing - I say nothing in terms of the research design. However, I hope to find the area where I can combine these two directions. Like the elections, where the political marketing is vivid and easier to research. 


In the next post I will touch upon the methods and again will try to explain why I always turn to opinion leadership and two-step flow theory. 
Enhanced by Zemanta

Jul 19, 2010

Blog popularity ranks in Finland

When you are faced with the prospect of identifying the influential bloggers, the sheer size of the blogosphere can seem daunting. I hope that it will be easier in case with the relatively small size of the Finnish bloggers' community. At a rough estimate my group of interest constitutes a bit more than 18,000 bloggers. Quite a few. However, the number of bloggers making the tops of popularity is, thankfully, much smaller.
I started filtering the blogs according to the simple criteria – (1) the topic and frequency of updates. (2) popularity ranking. I followed the guidelines of Scott (1991) and have, first, define a group of interest and then sample members in this group:

  1. Selecting bloggers on the basis of public issue involvement and production of content.
    The bloggers have been filtered, first, on the basis of the Public Issue Involvement-Production of Messages model (Park, et al. 2008). This model is designed to identify those who are highly involved with the current sociopolitical issues and actively produce comments and opinions in the blogosphere. These bloggers are viewed as power bloggers and constitute the group of interest in my study. For the purpose of this research the sociopolitical issues are (at the moment, but can be changed later) represented by two themes. One of them is political and goes to Eduskuntavaalit 2011 (General Finnish Elections 201. Another represents the public interest and hottest topic in the Finnish blogs over a certain period of time. According to Blogilista.fi, the Finnish blog search engine, the top-blogs are all about fashion, clothing, style, and shopping. I am not sure yet, but I would be also interested to cover this group of bloggers also.

    These two groups are so different in almost every term. The group of sociopolitical bloggers makes about 5,000 bloggers, and most popular of them are those who take the highest power positions in the real life. Their online influence is clearly rooted in their offline power status. The mechanisms of influence, structure of audience, and functionality of political blogs are obviously differ from all other types of blogs. Especially fashion blogs. The Finnish fashion bloggers (there are about 13 thousand fashion bloggers according to Blogilista.fi) are typically young girls (16-20 years old), writing about what they like in clothing, shopping, and socializing. The young fashion bloggers are very active with their updates, their audience is tenfold bigger in comparison with political blogs, and much more active in terms of comments. From being just popular, the fashion bloggers turn to the status of being influential. A number of clothing shops stake on that and start co-operating with the bloggers with their promotion campaigns.


  2. Selecting bloggers on the basis of popularity ranking.
    This stage is to sample the most popular bloggers out of the public bloggers (filtered in the earlier stage). Here I have to specify the metrics I used to rank the bloggers. The experienced Finnish bloggers, whom I interviewed before my research was started, mentioned that Blogilista.fi could not serve as an authoritative source of data. The problem is that Blogilista does not cover all or most of the Finnish bloggers. This service is developed only for those bloggers who are registered on it. Many of the long-practicing bloggers ignore the service, some of the just-started bloggers have not even heard about it. However, the engine counts something about 36,000 blogs registered and about 30 new blogs are being registered every day. I decided to start with Blogilista despite the critics. First of all I wanted to check how its ranking worked at least for the registered blogs.

    So, Blogilista provides ranking of the blogs within three categories: Hot List (Kuuma lista), Top List (Top-lista), and Most Read Blog List (Luetuimmat-lista). Hot List is more focused on what's new and hot in the Finnish blogosphere, calculating the updates, responds, inbound links, and citations. It ranks the blogs in accordance with the amount of the public interest they have attracted at the certain moment. The Top List ranks the bloggers on the basis of a number of followers (users who have subscribed for the blog or added it into their “Favourites”). Most Read Blog List calculates the visits within a 7-day period and ranks the bloggers who have the widest readership.
    On 8 July 2010, the top-10 of the Hot List was represented totally by the fashion bloggers with a slight mixture of photo and life style themes. The “Hottest” blogger was Milla (that day it was 112°, today it's gone up to 132.1°). She is 16-year old girl and her blog is titled “Playing Dress Up”. That time she had 529 subscribers (today it's already a hundred more), and 1,822 readers per week (today it is 3,598 readers per week). Today Milla is still leading the Hot List. No political or any other socially-important blogs have got into 10-hottest.
    The top-10 of Top List was represented by fashion bloggers + 1 blog with fun content (jokes, funny video, pictures) placed on the last tenth position. The first blogger in the rank was Nelliina with her blog “Nelliinan vaatehuone” (“Nelliina's wardrobe”),. The number of her subscribers constituted that day 3,005 (today it's 3,017) and number of reader per day was 9,663 (today it's 11,216). Her heat degree though was only 12° (today it's 13.3°). Today Nelliina is still leading the Top List. No political or any other socially-important blogs have got into 10-top.
    The top-10 of Most Read Blog List was represented by totally fashion bloggers with no exclusion for other topics. The first blogger in the rank was Emmi, 20-year old lady with her blog “No fashion victims”. The number of her subscribers constituted that day 2,479 (today it's 2,507) and number of reader per day was 9,663 (today it's 9,937). Her heat degree though was only 13.8° (today it's slightly less 13.7°). Today Nelliina is the second in the Most Read Blog List, while Nelliina with her “Nelliinan vaatehuone” comes as the first. No political or any other socially-important blogs have got into 10-top.
I was a bit puzzled when discovered no political or news blogs among the tops. My first guess was that the popular political bloggers (and respected politicians at the same time) are merely not registered for Blogilista. Therefore I have just blankly turned to Wikipedia to find out who are the most popular political bloggers in Finland. The encyclopedia provided me with several names, among which there were at least two registered at Blogilista.fi. Jurki JJ Kasvi, MP, member of the Green League, and famous blogger (according to Wikipedia). Just to compare: the number of his subscribers on 8 June 2010 constituted 570 (today it's the same) and number of reader per day was 62 (today it's 97). His heat degree was only 0.4° (no change for today). Another famous politician and blogger Erkki Tuomioja (again according to Wikipedia) was the Minister for Foreign Affair of Finland between 2000 and 2007. Currently he is MP and Chairman of the Grand Committee (EU affairs). Wikipedia says that Erkki Tuomioja “is considered to be one of the most widely read politicians still active on the political stage of Finland”. Blogilista says that the number of his subscribers on 8 June 2010 constituted 203 (today it's 202) and number of reader per day was 27 (today it's 26). His heat degree was 0.1° (no change for today). I did not find on Blogilista the blog of current Prime Minister of Finland Mari Kiviniemi. I decided to check the statistics myself. Although there was no data on subscribers or visitors, I found out that the Prime Minister had her last update on 31 May 2010 and got only 2 comments. Five posts in a row published before got no comments at all. It seems, Ms. Mari Kiviniemi is not very popular as a blogger.

If to draw the preliminary and very rough conclusions, I would say that even the most popular politicians might be loosers in blogosphere. It means that the online popularity is not always connected to the offline power status. On the other hand, it is quite understandable that political blog are not for “wide readership” and might be popular and influential in specific circles, so that the blog popularity metrics do not really work for them.

Another thing which is important to remember is that the technical metrics like calculation of inbound links, subscribers, page visits, readers, etc. can be used only for measuring popularity, but not influence. The blogosphere is a very dynamic system, where blogs and topics constantly rise and fall in popularity. For example, a certain blog may collect thousands of links in one day and it certainly indicates popularity. Though, thousands of links accumulated by a blog constantly over a protracted period of time might indicate that it is more than just popular. Therefore, in my research I will try to distinguish influential from popular. 

Jul 15, 2010

Why I put influential bloggers and opinion leaders together?

Long ago, when the world was local, opinion leaders were those whom we personally knew and respected for being informed and networked. We trusted their recommendations. We seek their advice. We refereed to them, when we wanted to increase the weight of our arguments. The world has changed, and now we live in, what they call, the age of digital communication. People make friends, go shopping, take votes, join communities, publish ideas, share opinions, and conduct many other  previously inconceivable activities online. Sometimes we hardly know whom we communicate with, because “on the Internet, nobody knows that you are a dog!”.

Does that mean that opinion leaders no longer exist? I mean, if communication environment has changed, so should the communication itself, right? Information that was once obtained second-hand from friends and acquaintances – in the tradition of two-step flow – is now found easily through the Internet, so we just probably do not need opinion leaders, or do we? The answer to the previous three questions is: while the communication environment is changing fast, the human habits of interaction remain as before. We may change our Internet identity every day, but the way how we search, evaluate and perceive information does not metamorphose that fast. We have the same emotional response whether online or offline. We have even invented the smiley icons to imitate the real-life facial expressions in our online conversations.
Thus, I find reasonable to assume that in the digital world, exactly like in its physical prototype, we still seek advice of those, whom we trust and respect for being informed and networked. I also find reasonable to assume that there should be no obvious differences between traditional opinion leaders and influential bloggers except the different communication environment and tools. However, I do not put an equal mark between them, because while having a definition of opinion leaders, we are still lack of understanding of who the influential bloggers are, and namely, why they are influential.
Enhanced by Zemanta

What is influence?

This is a crucial question in my research.  How do they do this? I mean how bloggers exert the influence? Who are those bloggers? Any one? Or some special charismatic people, "opinion leaders"? In the internet and academic literature there is very little research describing the methods to assess how bloggers exert influence and why such influence is ascribed to them. More specifically, the fact that bloggers represent the opinion leaders in the online environment seems to be assumed without having been proven. From the perspective of the communication studies, it is a significant omission. There is neither an extension of the two-step flow theory in its application to the new digital reality, nor any other recent model explaining how precisely the influential bloggers exert influence over the population of the blogosphere. By “how” I mean a clear notion of a mechanism which makes opinion leaders be responsible for diffusion processes, opinion formation, or other cognitive changes. 




 
Enhanced by Zemanta

Do opinion leaders exist in the blogosphere?

The influential bloggers are often named as opinion leaders. What I try to understand is what constitutes influence of bloggers and why it is equalled to opinion leadership. In my research I use the two-step flow theory (Lazarsfeld, Katz) as a theoretical footing, though it does not answer 2 questions: what influence is and how precisely the influence of opinion leaders shapes opinions and trends across entire communities? 
For this reason, I try to define the concept of influence from two approaches. The first approach is rooted in social psychology and defines influence as a capacity to produce a cognitive change in others (change of views, opinions, values, behaviour). The second approach is based on the blogosphere studies (web analytics), where influence stands for popularity (number of visitors, inbound links, comments, etc.). 
I have made a small investigation of these two approaches and come to the conclusion (1) that there is a clear difference between what is commonly understood as influence and popularity, and (2) that this distinction is empirically useful, when one tries to identify opinion leaders in the blogosphere and how they exert influence over non-influencers.
Enhanced by Zemanta